What does the Blue Moon Ice Cream taste like? Andrew Hoerth November 23, 2018 17:20 Updated Follow Blue Moon Ice Cream tastes like "Fruit Loops, Cotton Candy, and Sweet Fruit." It's very popular! Related articles What is the cost to ship? How do I know if my order shipped? Where can I find my tracking information? Why can't I order cheese or chocolate during certain times of the year? Are all of your products made in Wisconsin? Comments 0 comments Article is closed for comments.